"Outside a dog a book is man's best friend, inside a dog it is too dark to read!" -Groucho Marx========="The person, be it gentleman or lady, who has not pleasure in a good novel, must be intolerably stupid." -Jane Austen========="I don’t believe in the kind of magic in my books. But I do believe something very magical can happen when you read a good book."-JK Rowling========"I spend a lot of time reading." -Bill Gates=========“Ahhh. Bed, book, kitten, sandwich. All one needed in life, really.” -Jacqueline Kelly=========

Monday, September 30, 2024

TTT: Book I read because of the hype and what I thought of them


Top Ten Tuesday: Books I Read Because of the Hype... And What I Thought of Them

I am always scrutinizing book lists for my next reads. Sometimes the most popular books on the lists are fabulous and I am glad I paid attention. Other times I am surprised by how much I loved the books. Here are some recent examples of both:

1. Gather by Kenneth Cadow. A 2024 Printz Honor book. It seemed like I couldn't go anywhere on the Internet last year without someone raving about this book. I loved it, too. Thanks for the recommendation everyone!

2. The Song of Achilles by Madeline Miller. I read Circe several years ago for book club and loved it, so I added this book to my reading list. In the meantime I couldn't help noticing how many people were recommending it to each other. I just finished the audiobook with my husband and we both thought it was so well done.

3. North Woods by Daniel Mason. This book ended up on a lot of end of year lists in 2023 as one of if not the best book of the year. It was also thought to be a possible Pulitzer Prize contestant. So much hype and guess what, it was that good or better!


4. Wolf Hall by Hilary Mantel. Back in 2009/10 everyone in the bookish world was raving about this book. Everyone read it, except me. When I finally got around to it this year I was so disappointed. It wasn't terrible but it did not live up to the hype, in my mind anyway.

5. Night Watch by Jayne Anne Phillips. This book won the 2024 Pulitzer Prize for fiction. It came out of nowhere to win which I guess isn't a lot of hype but the award itself is big. Well anyway, I didn't particularly like the book and wish that North Woods (see above) had won instead.

6. The Fraud by Zadie Smith. Another book that got a lot of attention at the end of 2023 and placed on best-of lists. I disagreed with all of the people who were hyping this book. Ugh. I didn't like it.

7. The Covenant of Water by Abraham Verghese. When readers learned the author of Cutting for Stone was publishing a new book many, including myself, went into a sort of hyperdrive of expectation. And the book lived up to the hype big time.


8. The Wager by David Grann. This book got a lot of attention in 2023 for its excellent writing about a shipwreck in the 1700s. It seemed like everyone liked/loved this book except me and my family. We listened to the audiobook together. I liked it the best but gave it a rating of three.

9. Tomorrow, and Tomorrow, and Tomorrow by Gabrielle Zevin. The hype about this book has been pretty constant for more than a year. I  liked it a lot but have had to defend my decision with many other readers.


10. Before the Coffee Gets Cold by Toshikazu Kawaguchi. So many blogging friends read and loved this book. That is the only reason I read it, without doing any other research. It was not for me. In fact, I honestly didn't like it at all.



I hope I didn't diss your favorite book. I realize that how I feel about books may very well be able how I feel.

-Anne

Thursday, September 26, 2024

Review: THE GIRL I AM, WAS, AND NEVER WILL BE

Title:
The Girl I Am, Was, and Never Will Be: A Speculative Memoir of Transracial Adoption
by Shannon Gibney

Book Beginnings quote:
Prologue
I WAS BORN January 30, 1975, in Ann Arbor, Michigan
     The name on my birth certificate is Shannon Gibney, and my parents are listed as Jim and Susan Gibney. These are my white adoptive parents, who raised me. They gave me the loafers I remember wearing almost forty years ago. The backyard woods where my imagination first grew roots was theirs.
     The woman who gave birth to me and subsequently relinquished me was named Patricia Powers. She was a white, working-class Irish American woman who had a short relationship with my African American birth father, Boisey Collins, Jr. My birth mother named me Erin Powers after I was born, but I didn't find that out until I was nineteen. I possess no childhood memories of either of them.
Friday56 quote:
IN THIS SPACE, in the space between the stories ... in the space between what really happened, what could have happened, what almost did happen to another girl with another mother who relinquished her and another absent Black father ... in this space is where we exist, we have always existed. Where truth is born and exiled.
Summary: 
Part memoir, part speculative fiction, The Girl I Am, Was, and Never Will Be explores the often surreal experience of growing up as a mixed-Black transracial adoptee.

It is a book woven from the author's true story of growing up as a mixed-Black transracial adoptee and fictional story of Erin Powers, the name Shannon was given at birth, a child raised by a white, closeted lesbian.

At its core, the novel is a tale of two girls on two different timelines occasionally bridged by a mysterious portal and their shared search for a complete picture of their origins. Gibney surrounds that story with reproductions of her own adoption documents, letters, family photographs, interviews, medical records, and brief essays on the surreal absurdities of the adoptee experience.

The end result is a remarkable portrait of an American experience rarely depicted in any form. (Publisher)
Review: As I was preparing myself to review The Girl I Am I ran into the word "surreal." That is exactly the right word to describe this book. Read the prologue and the book is obviously a memoir. Then comes the interlude starting with IN THIS SPACE (Friday56 quote) and the reader realizes that something other than a memoir is at hand. Let me correct that, some chapters titled "Shannon Gibney," are a memoir about what life was like growing up transracial in a white family, how Shannon found her birth mother, what that tenuous relationship was like, and how she discovered he father had died when she was six. Then there were wormholes, time travel, and alternate histories. Those chapters were titled "Erin Powers." Here the author is imagining a different life for herself but is somehow aware of her other life. Confusing. Surreal.

Interspersed throughout the two concurrent stories are actual documents and letters about Shannon's adoption and from her birth mother. There are family trees and stories about the alternate world other adoptees have had to deal with. I am not sure why this book was published as a YA title. Not only is it a YA  title it won a Printz Honor award this year. Perhaps the publisher thought it should be YA because the author is nineteen for a good portion of the action. Perhaps the publisher or the author thought that other teens need a book that covers the topic of transracial adoption and how confusing life can be, often is, for such kids. Whatever the reason, I had a hard time imagining any teen reading this book, or not setting this book aside because it is so confusing. Sigh. That said I made it to the end and was glad to see that Shannon Gibney was grateful to her adopted family and expressed love to her parents and brothers.

My Rating: 3 stars

 

-Anne



Monday, September 23, 2024

TTT: My Fall Reading List (and how I did on my summer list)



Top Ten Tuesday: Fall Reading List. 
Below the line is how I did on my summer reading list.
 
Fall reading list: 

Book Club Selections:
  1. House Lessons by Erica Bauermeister (October)
  2. Women in the Castle by Jessica Shattuck (November)
  3. The Japanese Lover by Isabel Allende (December)  
Challenge Books:
  1. Classics Club Spin Book TBA from this list -- possibly A Christmas Carol by C. Dickens
  2. A Past Pulitzer Prize winner from list -- possibly All the King's Men by Robert Penn Warren
  3. Printz Award winner or honor book from this list -- The Girl I Am, Was, and Never Will Be by S. Gibney
  4. Past Women's Prize winner or finalist --  possibly Piranesi by S. Clarke
  5. Two National Book Award titles (finalists/winners) -- finalists announced October 1st
    1. -
    2. -
  6. Novella November -- I hope to read 2-4 novellas in November
    1. - Possibly- Dept. of Speculation by Offill
    2. - Possibly- The Turn of the Screw by Henry James
       
Books I've already started, recently acquired, and/or have on-hold at the library:
  1.  James by Percival Everett
  2.  How to Be Both by Ali Smith
  3.  The Lion Women of Tehran by Marjan Kamali
  4. The Not-Quite-States of America: Dispatches From the Territories and Other Far-Flung Outposts of the USA by Doug Mack
  5. Olga Dies Dreaming by Xochitl Gonzalez
  6. A Death in the Family by James Agee
  7. Tell Me Everything by Elizabeth Strout
  8. The Portable Veblen by Elizabeth McKenzie
 
 
 

Update: How I did on my summer reading list.
 Yellow: completed. 
Aqua: in progress
Green:  not completed, DNF, or currently reading
Light pink: Did not get to yet!

Summer reading list:

Book Club Selections:
  1. Sarah Canary by Karen Joy Fowler (July, Group #1)
  2. Killers of a Certain Age by Deanna Raybourn (August, Group #1)
  3. Night Watch by Jayne Anne Phillips (August, Group #2) 
  4. Pride, Prejudice, and Other Flavors by Sonali Dev (September, Group #1) 

Challenge Books:
  1. Classics Club Spin Book TBA from this list -- A Bell for Adano by Hersey
  2. A Past Pulitzer Prize winner from list -- The Known World by Edward P. Jones
  3. Printz Award winner or honor book from this list -- Gather by Kenneth Cadow
  4. My One Big Book Challenge book -- Wolf Hall by Mantel 
  5. Big Book Summer Challenge -- The Women by Kristin Hannah
  6. Women's Prize winner or finalist --  Brotherless Night by V.V. Ganeshananthan
     
Books I've already started, recently acquired, have on-hold at the library, or the remaining books on my 20 Books of Summer Challenge list:
  1. The Thursday Murder Club by Richard Osman
  2.  Wandering Star by Tommy Orange
  3.  North Woods by Daniel Mason
  4.  The Berry Pickers by Amanda Peters
  5.  The House of Broken Angels by Luis Alberto Urrea
  6.  Gather by Kenneth Cadow
  7.  The Bee Sting by Paul Murray -DNF
  8.  Tiny Beautiful Things by Cheryl Strayed
  9.  Symphony of Secrets Brendan Slocomb
  10. Suffering is Never for Nothing by Elisabeth Elliot
  11. Too Much Happiness by Alice Munro 
 
I inspected this list frequently during the summer to make sure I was reading all the books I'd placed on it. It became an obsession to finish the whole list and I almost made it. I read over 100 pages of The Bee Sting before I decided I would not finish it. It was too long and frustrating to read and I gave it the heave-ho.
 


-Anne

Saturday, September 21, 2024

Sunday Salon--- A wonderful week


Weather:
Lovely, mild temperatures and sunny, It is shaping up to be a nice Fall.

Jamie is four! We took him to the Washington State Fair on his birthday and had so much fun! See photo collage above. (Ah to be retired and to go to the fair on a Monday!)

This quote from an article written by a woman wishing she could say this to her children before she dies. I love it so much: 
"If I could, I would stay forever. I would listen, encourage and console. I would shade you like an oak tree on sweltering summer days. I would protect you like the fir tree against cold winds. I would offer blooms of spring to celebrate your dreams accomplished. I would burst with the colors of autumn to remind you that even as dark days come, so does hope." -By 
I choose joy. A few reasons I think Kamala Harris will win:
  • Demographics have changed since 2016. Women aged 18 to 29 became significantly more liberal than the previous generation of young women. Today, around 40 percent identify as liberal, compared with just 19 percent who say they’re conservative. Men have stayed about the same. In a year where women's rights are on the ballot this may be enough to tip the balance for Harris. (NYT)
  • The polls look good. There was a debate bounce. Trump and Harris were essentially tied before, but the new poll of 1,755 U.S. adults — one of the first conducted after the Sept. 10 debate — shows Harris (50%) surging to a five-point lead over Trump (45%) among registered voters in a head-to-head matchup. (Yahoo News)
  • People like Harris. Her favorability is 50-44%, +6%; compared to Trump whose favorability is -20%. (AP)
  • People are expecting Harris to win. As Noelle-Neumann showed decades ago, expectations of a win are a leading indicator of engagement and turn-out. (WaPo)
  • Trump is hemorrhaging support. Republicans for Harris is expanding. Yesterday it was Republicans who worked for Reagan who signed on their support for Harris (Mother Jones).
  • Kamala has the support of influential people. Did you see the event hosted by Oprah this week? If not, here is the link. Set aside an hour and half. You will be so happy you did. Unite for America.
  • Tim Walz is a gem. Watch this short clip of Tim Walz doing service on his '79 International Harvester Scout. It will make you love him more! (And he gets in a good dig about Project 2025.)
  • The Electoral College map seems to be expanding for Harris. North Carolina was moved from Toss Up to Lean Dem this week. (The Guardian)
My Vote Forward project table. Pretty stamps, colored pens, and addresses.


But don't get complacent-- DO SOMETHING! Since I live in a safely blue state I've been writing letters to folks in swing districts, in swing states through Vote Forward. In fact I had a few friends join me this week to help me write them. Follow the link if you'd like to write to potential voters. IF WE FIGHT WE WIN! After I finish up the last 30 letters I will write postcards to voters. It makes me feel like I am having an impact. If you live in a swing or red state and have energy, you might consider phone-banking or door-belling. Contact a Democratic office near you, go to Go.KamalaHarris.com or Women for Harris.



Books! Books! Books! I finished My 21st Century Pulitzer Prize Fiction Winners Challenge this week. It has taken me years but I am finished. Now I can read whatever Pulitzers I want without the pressure to read specific books! Whew. I also finished up all my blogging so the project is DONE!
  • My 21st Century Pulitzer Prize Fiction Challenge Wrap-up. Link.
  • The Known World review. The last book read for the project.
  • Recap of the four winners which I read before becoming a book blogger. Link.
  • I finished another project, years in the making, this week, too. I read the third book in the Justice Trilogy by Louise Erdrich and did a write up on the three books.
Baked Feta: This time of year is so wonderful with the temperatures down but the garden still growing. We still have an abundance of tomatoes, especially cherry tomatoes, and basil. Tonight (Saturday) I made a baked feta which used both those items. I got the idea from my physical therapist when I gave her a bag of cherry toms and she told me what she was going to make with them. Yum!!! I still have good flavors in my mouth. This is the recipe I used.

Raise your hand if you agree! (Thanks Kathy, for sharing this with me.)


-Anne

Review: THE KNOWN WORLD



Winner of the 2004 Pulitzer Prize for Fiction, The Known World is "an ambitious, luminously written novel that ranges seamlessly between the past and future and back again to the present, it weaves together the lives of freed and enslaved blacks, whites, and Indians -- and allows all of us a deeper understanding of the enduring multidimensional world created by the institution of slavery" (Publisher).

The Known World tells the story of Henry Townsend, a black farmer and former slave in antebellum Virginia. His former owner, William Robbins, is the most powerful man in Manchester County and he brings Henry under his tutelage. By the time his parents, free Blacks, secured his freedom, Henry is determined to own slaves himself, against the wishes his father, Augustus. But why would a former slave want to enslave men? This uncomfortable question pervades the whole text. Why? Why, indeed!?

One answer is because slavery is legal, so why not? Another answer is Henry wants to prove that he can be a kind, generous owner, better than any White owners. But the truth of the matter is owning other people always brings out the worst in people. Henry might have thought of himself as kind and generous but that doesn't explain why he had the ear cut off one of his slaves who tried to escape. That certainly doesn't sound like kindness to me. By the time Henry dies he owns 33 slaves and none are especially sad that he is gone. His estate falls to Caledonia, Henry's wife. In her grief and ignorance about the running of the estate, chaos ensues, with several slaves escaping or disappearing, and the remaining souls turning on each other in anger and spite.

There are no heroes or true villains in The Known World because all the characters are poisoned by the rot caused by the institution of slavery, rotten to the core. No one escaped the stench.

Jones, a writing professor living in Washington DC, brought the story alive in a variety of ways. One was his use of language. The language of the book sounded authentic to the time period even to my 21 Century ears. Here is an example -- "It was said by many a slave that a servant’s feeling about a master could be discerned on any given day by whether the slave called him “Master,” “Marse,” or “Massa.” “Marse” could sound like a curse if the right woman said it in just the right way."

The Known World was identified as the fourth best book on the New York Times Best Books of the 21 Century, a list published this summer. It was the the best novel on the list written by an American author. When I saw the list I couldn't believe it. The Known World is the fourth best book of the century? How could that be? I hadn't even heard of it until I saw it on a list of past Pulitzer winners. Can a book really be lauded and overlooked at the same time? I guess so. Winner of the Pulitzer, the fourth best book of the century, and still few know about the book.  Well, I'm here to tell you that this book is worth the time it takes to read it. Yes, it is an uncomfortable topic, one that history has ignored, Blacks owning slaves, but one very worthy of our attention.

My rating: 4 stars.

-Anne

Recaps of four Pulitzer Prize fiction winners I read a long time ago



Several years ago I set myself the challenge of reading all the 21st Century Pulitzer Prize Fiction winners. This week I finished the last book on the list, the 2004 winner, The Known World by Jones. As I was writing a summary post of my challenge I realized I hadn't posted reviews for four of the books, all read before I became a book blogger. This morning I spent an hour or so looking through my book journals, where I kept a record of the books read. I would usually write a quick little reaction to each book, not really a review but more just a snapshot of how I felt about the book. For each book's recap, I will share the exact note written at the time of its reading, a short summary of the book from the publisher, and my recollection of the book from the perspective of time.

2002 Winner --- 

Empire Falls
by Richard Russo (Vintage Books, 2001)
Summary: 
Welcome to Empire Falls, a blue-collar town full of abandoned mills whose citizens surround themselves with the comforts and feuds provided by lifelong friends and neighbors and who find humor and hope in the most unlikely places, in this Pulitzer Prize-winning novel by Richard Russo.

Miles Roby has been slinging burgers at the Empire Grill for 20 years, a job that cost him his college education and much of his self-respect. What keeps him there? It could be his bright, sensitive daughter Tick, who needs all his help surviving the local high school. Or maybe it’s Janine, Miles’ soon-to-be ex-wife, who’s taken up with a noxiously vain health-club proprietor. Or perhaps it’s the imperious Francine Whiting, who owns everything in town–and seems to believe that “everything” includes Miles himself. In Empire Falls
 Richard Russo delves deep into the blue-collar heart of America in a work that overflows with hilarity, heartache, and grace. (Publisher)
Snapshot of my reaction to book in August 2003:
"I had this book recommended to me so many times by so many people I thought I'd better read it. I liked it and found the character development good." 

Recollection with the perspective of time:
First, I want to cover my eyes over my short snapshot. How unhelpful were those thoughts?  I actually have very little memory of the book. I remember liking the main character, Miles Roby, and that the book was set in a down-and-out community. I realize that is not very helpful either. As a high school librarian I would often converse with teachers about their favorite books and Empire Falls was the absolute favorite of a Social Studies teacher. In fact, he liked it so much, no other book could get anywhere near it so he was living in a constant state of disappointment about other books thanks to this one. I'm thinking this book deserves a reread.

2003 Winner --

Middlesex
by Jeffrey Eugenides (Picador, 2002)
Summary: 
Middlesex tells the breathtaking story of Calliope Stephanides, and three generations of the Greek-American Stephanides family, who travel from a tiny village overlooking Mount Olympus in Asia Minor to Prohibition-era Detroit, witnessing its glory days as the Motor City and the race riots of 1967 before moving out to the tree-lined streets of suburban Grosse Pointe, Michigan. To understand why Calliope is not like other girls, she has to uncover a guilty family secret, and the astonishing genetic history that turns Callie into Cal, one of the most audacious and wondrous narrators in contemporary fiction. Lyrical and thrilling, Middlesex is an exhilarating reinvention of the American epic. (Publisher)
Snapshot from February 2007: 
"I listened to this book club selection in audiobook format and thoroughly enjoyed it. I realized that a great deal of my pleasure in the book was derived by the audio format as other gals in my club, who all read it, found it tedious or difficult. The protagonist, Cal or Calli, was a hermaphrodite, which is an unusual topic. I did love the the prose and also the many references to the pop culture of the 1970s."

Recollection:
Clearly I wrote my snapshot reactions for myself, never thinking I'd share the drivel with others. Middlesex has aged very well in my memory. What is shocking about my reaction is how I missed so many of the parts of the multifaceted plot: In addition to Cal's transgender trauma/dilemma, there was a fairly detailed account of the Armenian genocide, and likewise the details about Detroit as the Motor City and its 1967 Race Riot. It was the first time I'd read anything about those events. In my ranking of Pulitzers, I ranked Middlesex as "Very Good." I bet if I reread it, it might get an upgrade to "Great."

2006 winner --

March
by Geraldine Brooks (Penguin, 2005)
Summary:
From the author of the acclaimed Year of Wonders, a historical novel and love story set during a time of catastrophe, on the front lines of the American Civil War. Acclaimed author Geraldine Brooks gives us the story of the absent father from Louisa May Alcott's Little Women—and conjures a world of brutality, stubborn courage and transcendent love. An idealistic abolitionist, March has gone as chaplain to serve the Union cause. But the war tests his faith not only in the Union—which is also capable of barbarism and racism—but in himself. As he recovers from a near-fatal illness, March must reassemble and reconnect with his family, who have no idea of what he has endured. A love story set in a time of catastrophe, March explores the passions between a man and a woman, the tenderness of parent and child, and the life-changing power of an ardently held belief. (Publisher)
Snapshot from February 2008:
"This is Little Women from Mr. March's point of view. It covers the time preceding and during the Civil War. The book was well-written and a good match with Alcott's style. the historical information was especially thought-provoking but I didn't think Brooks developed her characters fully. Many members in my book club liked the book more than I did. One interesting note, Brooks utilized the journals of Bronson Alcott [Louisa May Alcott's father] for information for this book which brought real authenticity to references to the time period and realistic descriptions of the horrors of war."

Recollections: I am a huge Geraldine Brooks fan. I've read five of her books and want to read two others. Oddly I can remember just about all the details of the other four books and just about none from this one. Unlike the other books in this batch, I have no desire to reread March.

2009 winner --

Olive Kitteridge
by Elizabeth Strout (Random House, 2008)

Summary:
At times stern, at other times patient, at times perceptive, at other times in sad denial, Olive Kitteridge, a retired schoolteacher, deplores the changes in her little town of Crosby, Maine, and in the world at large, but she doesn’t always recognize the changes in those around her: a lounge musician haunted by a past romance; a former student who has lost the will to live; Olive’s own adult child, who feels tyrannized by her irrational sensitivities; and her husband, Henry, who finds his loyalty to his marriage both a blessing and a curse.

As the townspeople grapple with their problems, mild and dire, Olive is brought to a deeper understanding of herself and her life—sometimes painfully, but always with ruthless honesty. Olive Kitteridge offers profound insights into the human condition—its conflicts, its tragedies and joys, and the endurance it requires. (Publisher)

Snapshot from August 2010:
"Thirteen vignettes all involving Olive Kitteridge as either a major or a secondary character. Olive is a cranky, unlovable, retired JH Math teacher. She lives in Crosby, Maine. She seems to delight in the pain of others yet is occasionally capable of remarkable acts of love and compassion. I really enjoyed this book and the contemplation of such a multifaceted person."

Recollections: Olive Kitteridge, the character, has made an appearance in several of Strout's other books, including the sequel to this book, Olive, Again. Back in 2010 when we read this book for book club, I recall a large part of our discussion centering around the question, Can you like a book when the main character is so unlovable? I really enjoy all of the Strout books I've read and I enjoy remeeting characters in them. I don't think I need to reread Olive Kitteridge but I do want to read Strout's new book, Tell Me Everything, where I understand, I will once again meet Olive.

This was a fun activity. Maybe I should do it for other books I read before my book blogging days. I hope you enjoyed these short recaps, too.

-Anne

Thursday, September 19, 2024

YA Review: GATHER


Title:
Gather by Kenneth M. Cadow

Book Beginnings quote: 
You see people doing things they shouldn't. Sometimes you mind your own business. Other times you might say something, but it's hard to do that if you've been caught red-handed yourself.
Friday56 quote: 
After class, I duck into the nurse's office. I take my time using her Old Spice [deodorant], but finally, Pam's like, "Ian, you'll be late for advisory," and I'm like, "Advisory is the worst twenty minutes of my day. Mr. Z pretty much gave up after we wasted two weeks talking about kindness. You want to torture people? Talk to them about kindness for two weeks. What's kind about that?"

Summary:

Ian Gray isn’t supposed to have a dog, but a lot of things that shouldn’t happen end up happening anyway. And Gather, Ian’s adopted pup, is good company now that Ian has to quit the basketball team, find a job, and take care of his mom as she tries to overcome her opioid addiction. Despite the obstacles thrown their way, Ian is determined to keep his family afloat no matter what it takes. And for a little while, things are looking up.  Ian makes friends, and his fondness for the outdoors and for fixing things lands him work helping neighbors. But an unforeseen tragedy results in Ian and his dog taking off on the run, trying to evade a future that would mean leaving their house and their land. Even if the community comes together to help him, would Ian and Gather have a home to return to? (Publisher)

Review: This book, written in a unique first person perspective, just about broke my heart. Ian is trying to hold everything together even though the main adults in his life don't or can't help him. What with a mother who is an addict, a father and grandmother who have abandoned him, and a grandfather who has died, Ian just keeps on scrambling trying his hardest to save his beloved land. But one young teenager battling against the world is a big ask.

I loved Ian's voice in Gather. It is just what one would imagine a teenager's voice would sound like. The Friday56 quote is a good example of that voice: You want to torture people? Talk to them about kindness for two weeks. What's kind about that?" Irreverent and wise at the same time. Ian is also irresistible. He can fix just about anything and manages to make friends along the way because of his skills. It is a refreshing to have a teenage character who can rely on his own know-how and ingenuity rather than a sullen one who feels sorrow for himself while he wittles away time playing video games or watching TV.

As an old retired high school librarian I can't help but ask myself the big question, "What teen would be attracted to this book?" It won a Printz Honor in 2024 for good reason but are teenagers attracted to award books like I am? Not usually. I think the kids that need this book are the kids like Ian, who walk the halls in every school -- the loners, on the surface anyway, who are trying to hold their worlds together with baling wire and spit. There are plenty of those kids in every school. Your assignment, school librarians, go out and find them. Get this book in their hands. Let them have plenty of time to read it since the book is rather long, 325 pages. And when they return it, be open to talking to them about it. Good luck! It just might change their life.

Every year, now that I'm retired from my role as a teen librarian, I tell myself I no longer need to read the YA winners of the Printz Award. Then I read books like Gather, and I say, "Nah, I'm gonna keep reading YA books. They help keep me young."

Rating: 5 stars.

 


-Anne

Tuesday, September 17, 2024

Review: The Justice Trilogy by Louise Erdrich


Back in the summer of 2016 my book group read and discussed The Round House by Louise Erdrich. It was the first Erdrich book I'd finished. Several years previously I had attempted to read Love Medicine (1984) but didn't make it to the end. The Round House, for contrast, I loved. In fact, everyone in the club loved it. We had a very spirited discussion and we still talk about the book occasionally when we discuss favorites. At the time of our reading The Round House we knew it was the 2012 National Book Award winner. We didn't know it was the second book in a loosely connected trilogy by Erdrich. Not until the same book club read another Erdrich novel, La Rose (2016), did I see a connection between the two books: justice -- revenge in one; forgiveness in the other. It wasn't until I was doing a bit of research on past Pulitzer Prize winners and finalists did I learn Erdrich's book The Plague of Doves (2008) was the first book in the Justice series. So now, taking a very circuitous route, I have finally finished all three and I'm ready to handle the task of reviewing the whole series.

The Plague of Doves (2008)

The unsolved murder of a farm family over fifty years ago still haunts the inhabitants of Pluto, North Dakota, a small, white community near an Ojibwe reservation. In retribution for the murders, other farmers of German descent, find three Indians and lynch them without a trial. To this day everyone is in agreement that the three men were not the murderers and the real culprit was never found nor brought to justice. There were two survivors of this event -- a baby girl found alive in her crib at the scene of the first murder, and Mooshum, an Indian teen who was cut down from the tree before he died. Later Mooshum, who was nearing the end of his life, told his granddaughter Evelina Harp what happened that terrible day. 

There are four narrators in The Plague of Doves (read by four voice actors in the audiobook): 1. Evelina, Mooshum's granddaughter. 2. Judge Brazil Coutts who has an affair with the woman who was once the surviving baby now grown-up; he eventually marries Geraldine, Evelina's aunt. 3. Marn Wolde is the daughter of a nearby farmer; she marries Billy, whose sister Maggie, has a child with the husband of Neve, another of Evelina's aunts. This baby, Corwin Peace, grows up to be Eveline's first love interest. 4. Dr. Cordelia Lochren the grown up 'surviving baby' (who has an affair with Brazil) later becomes best friends with Neve. I actually looked for a family tree on the Internet, because this tangle of people was so confusing to me. I can only imagine what you, dear reader, are thinking about this story right now. I'm sure it is mind-boggling to you. Just suffice it to say, that the indigenous and white members of this community have long been intermarrying and are all related to each other in some way or another. Each of the four narrators tell their stories which cements the idea of how tangled up their lives are with each other, both the families of the lynched men and the families of those who did the lynching. Bruce Barcott, writing for the NYT, wraps it up this way, "These folks don’t need closets to hold their skeletons, they need storage units."

Barcott goes on to say The Plague of Doves is about a community "maddeningly strangled by its own history." Which brings up the concept of justice. Can people really ever recover from a tragedy when they know the culprit(s) have never come to justice? How does a whole community find redemption from all the guilt they have experienced their whole lives?

My husband and I listened to the audiobook of The Plague of Doves together. Afterwards we sat down with a blank piece of paper and attempted to draw out a family tree showing the interrelationships between all the main (and a few of the side) characters.  Don was especially impressed by the intertwining stories and the ability Erdrich has to write such multilayered mythology.

My rating 4 stars.

The Round House (2012)

Over a decade has passed since the events of the first book. In The Round House Geraldine and Brazil Couts are home on a Sunday, when Geraldine, who manages tribal enrollment, receives a telephone call. She tells her thirteen-year-old son, Joe, she needs to go pick something up from the office. Hours later she returns and Joe's childhood life will never be the same. His mother has been raped and beaten. Nothing the boy does will bring back the idyllic "before" days and Joe becomes obsessed with finding out who did this thing to his mother. He wants to bring that person to justice. But justice to a kid looks a lot like vengeance and that is exactly what Joe and his friend, Cappy, set out to do.  And justice on a reservation doesn't look the same as it does in the rest of the country, where White men make the rules.
The novel, told through the eyes of a grown Joe looking back at himself as a boy, combines a coming-of-age story (think Stand By Me) with a crime and vengeance story while exploring Erdrich’s trademark themes: the struggle of Native Americans to maintain their identity; the legacy of the troubled, unequal relationship between Native Americans and European Americans, a relationship full of hatred but also mutual dependence; the role of the Catholic Church within a Native American community that has not entirely given up its own beliefs or spirituality. (Kirkus Reviews)
Like I said in my intro, The Round House was my first complete Erdrich book and I fell under the author's spell. Even though the summary is very depressing and the situation very dire, I remember there being many funny moments in the book. Laugh out loud funny. Mooshum, now claiming to be 112 years not only provides needed historical context but quite a bit of this humor. I also appreciated learning about the Ojibwe traditions around the round house. I had my eyes opened.

The Round House won the 2012 National Book Award. This is what the judges said about their selection, 
In this haunting, powerful novel, Erdrich tells the story of a family and community nearly undone by violence. Using the quiet, reflective voice of a young boy forced into an early adulthood following a brutal assault on his mother, Erdrich has created an intricately layered novel that not only untangles our nation’s history of moral and judicial failure, but also offers a portrait of a community sustained by its traditions, values, faith, and stories. (NBA)
After we finished the audiobook for The Plague of Doves, my husband expressed interest in reading the rest of the trilogy. I jumped at the idea and committed to listening to The Round House with him. Now to find the time.

My rating: 5 stars.

LaRose (2016)

The central question in LaRose by Louise Erdrich is: Can a person "do the worst thing possible and still be loved"?

Landreaux Iron does the worst thing. When he is out hunting one day, he accidentally hits and kills the young son, Dusty, of his best friend. Set in North Dakota on the Ojibwe Indian Reservation, Landreaux and his wife seek tribal remedies in a sweat lodge and by talking to their priest about ways to deal with their guilt. Ultimately they decide to give their son, LaRose, to Dusty's family following an ancient tradition as a way of seeking pardon. Dusty's parents, Nola and Peter Ravich, are obviously tentative in accepting another child as "payment" for their lost son but eventually find that LaRose does indeed fulfill a deep need for solace in their hearts.

LaRose, who is named for a long line of ancestors with the same name, is really a remarkable kid who seems to have an intuition what he needs to do to help both families heal from this horrible situation. He seems to be able to draw upon the strength and lessons learned from his previous namesakes, whom we meet in short, retrospective chapters.

In the hands of most authors LaRose would be a completely sentimental, sad book, but not in the very adept hands of Louise Erdrich. She understands how to tell a story which compels the reader to confront the situation at hand without being sappy. Along the way we even gain insights and knowledge about Native American culture and family structure.

While the first two books in the series on justice delve into the concepts of guilt and vengeance, LaRose addresses the concept of forgiveness and the wisdom behind Native justice practices. If possible I think I liked this book best of the three, but that may be only because I wrote a detailed review of it and published it here on my blog, (LeRose) so I may remember it best. Others in my book club did not feel the same way, complaining about all the mysticism in the stories. I tried to stick up for it and explain how magical realism is used to describe concepts. They were having none of it so I let it go. I also was the only one who listened to the book, so perhaps being immersed in the audio version helped me appreciate the story more. Anyway, keep this in mind if you are trying to decide if you want to read or listen to the book.

My rating: 5 stars.

As I was preparing myself to write about Louise Erdrich's Justice series, I kept running into references to a collection of essays compiled in a book titled Louise Erdrich's Justice Trilogy: Cultural and Critical Contexts edited by Connie A. Jacobs and Nancy J. Petersen. I haven't read it, and doubt I will as it seems like a book which may end up on a college class syllabus, but I thought I would mention it here. This is the synopsis:
Louise Erdrich is one of the most important, prolific, and widely read contemporary Indigenous writers. Here leading scholars analyze the three critically acclaimed recent novels-- The Plague of Doves (2008), The Round House (2012), and LaRose (2016)--that make up what has become known as Erdrich's "justice trilogy." Set in small towns and reservations of northern North Dakota, these three interwoven works bring together a vibrant cast of characters whose lives are shaped by history, identity, and community. Individually and collectively, the essays herein illuminate Erdrich's storytelling abilities; the complex relations among crime, punishment, and forgiveness that characterize her work; and the Anishinaabe contexts that underlie her presentation of character, conflict, and community. The volume also includes a reader's guide to each novel, a glossary, and an interview with Erdrich that will aid in readers' navigation of the justice novels. These timely, original, and compelling readings make a valuable contribution to Erdrich scholarship and, subsequently, to the study of Native literature and women's authorship as a whole.(Publisher)
If you haven't read, or even heard of, these wonderful book, this wonderful series, I hope my reviews will give you the little push you need to read them for yourself.

-Anne

Monday, September 16, 2024

TTT: Redeemed characters


Top Ten Tuesday: Redeemed Characters 

1. Fitzwilliam Darcy in Pride and Prejudice by Jane Austen. He was such a snob but ended up using his power and presitigue for good to benefit the Bennet family.

2. Ebenezer Scrooge in A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens. Scrooge didn't believe in Christmas until he was visited by the ghosts of Christmas past, present, and future. His transformation was complete.

3. Jean Valjean in Les Miserables by Victor Hugo. Valjean is imprisoned for stealing bread but ends up killing a man while inside the prison. When he escapes he comes to understand that only through love can he be redeemed and the rest of his life is dedicated to good works.

4. Severus Snape in Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows by J.K. Rowlings. He redeemed himself after Lily Potter's death by becoming a double agent working for Dumbledore against Voldemort.

5. Edmund in The Lion, the Witch, and the Wardrobe by C.S. Lewis. Edmund ratted out his siblings to the White Witch, but Aslan redeemed him, saving him to fight alongside his brother Peter and other magical beasts against the witch and her minions.

6. Werner Pfennig in All the Light We Cannot See by Anthony Doerr. Werner isn't a bad person he is just forced to use his talents with radios to further the Nazi cause. He is redeemed when he saves Marie-Laure in a French town where he is sent to find and destroy her.

7. Victoria Jones in The Language of Flowers by Vanessa Diffenbaugh. Victoria has aged out of foster care and now she is trying to mother herself after having few positive role models in her life. Flowers and friends come together to help redeem Victoria from her past.

8. Billy Dunne in Daisy Jones and the Six by Taylor Jenkins Reid. Billy's rise to fame comes at a cost to his family and his one true love, Camila. In an act of true redemption, he saves not only Daisy Jones but himself, finding his way home to his family.

9. Agnes in Burial Rites by Hannah Kent. The last person ever put to death by the state of Iceland, Agnes finds redemption in her time with a priest and the family where she is staying as she replays her life and her choices.

10. Circe in Circe by Madeline Miller.  Miller redeems Circe, of Greek Mythology. She is no longer the bad girl of the myths.




-Anne