"Outside a dog a book is man's best friend, inside a dog it is too dark to read!" -Groucho Marx========="The person, be it gentleman or lady, who has not pleasure in a good novel, must be intolerably stupid." -Jane Austen========="I don’t believe in the kind of magic in my books. But I do believe something very magical can happen when you read a good book."-JK Rowling========"I spend a lot of time reading." -Bill Gates=========“Ahhh. Bed, book, kitten, sandwich. All one needed in life, really.” -Jacqueline Kelly=========

Saturday, December 7, 2024

Sunday Salon --- Stuff!

Too many mugs

Weather: RAIN.

Stuff #1 --  We put out our Christmas decorations this week. Most of those decorations are stored in five storage tubs which we lug in from the shed once a year. As we open each tub we paw through to find the favored decorations and place them around the house in particular spots. The non-favored items seem to live endlessly in the tubs, never getting pulled out to decorate the house. Why do we keep this stuff? Clearly one of the reason is sentimentality -- "Oh, here is the ornament C. made in daycare." "Oh look, here is the sweet decoration we bought our first year of marriage." "I remember when your grandma gave us this bobble." -- Other decorations were given to us by relatives and we wouldn't want them to think we aren't grateful, even if they probably don't remember giving us that gift. So why keep them. Every year we say we are going to sort through the decorations in the tubs and offload the stuff but by the time we are putting things away in January, we don't feel like taking the extra time and just cram stuff back in for another year. Ha!

Stuff #2 -- My mother, aged 95, has been sorting and off-loading her stuff for years. She still lives on her own but wants to see her treasures rehomed while she is still alive so she can enjoy them in their new homes when she visits. Every time we drop by she has a little pile of items she wants to go though, hoping we will take her old stuff to our house. Most of the items in the piles are indeed stuff -- dusty candles, linens with stains, stemware with chips -- but every once in a while there is a treasure or two. This past week she gave my grandsons, her great-grandsons, a pile of old children's books. Not sure all of these are special books, but my daughter was delighted to see Moses the Kitten by James Herriot. It was one of her childhood favorites. Diamonds in the rough.

Stuff #3 -- Like mother, like daughter. I've started off-loading my stuff onto my daughters, too, though on a much smaller scale. Rita inherited old cookie cutters from me last week. I tried to get her to take the jello molds and Rice Crispy treats molds, too, but she was not tricked. Carly willingly took my unique gourd nativity set from the tub where it has lived for a few years. But she couldn't help teasing me for turning into my mother as an off-loader of stuff.

Stuff #4 -- Over a year ago we moved a lot of stuff out of our bonus room, where old stuff had gone to die for years. We were getting new carpet so we boxed up everything and put the boxes in the garage. We never moved the stuff back and they are still in the boxes in the garage. A few weeks ago I contemplated out loud how we should just throw the boxes out without looking inside. We lived for all this time without missing the stuff. Why not?

Stuff #5 -- Thinking about stuff has got me noticing all the stuff. Right before the housekeeper was set to arrive, I looked around my kitchen and noticed all the stuff on the counter. This is the stuff I use frequently but have no room in the cupboards because of the stuff I don't use that is taking up space. Stuff like the espresso maker we haven't used for years; the George Foreman grill which we used to use all the time when my husband was serving in the military overseas but haven't used since then; the teacups and saucers that match my dishes but we don't use because everyone prefers to use coffee mugs; and then the plethora of mugs in general. Here is an irony -- I have a variety of boxes of teabags I don't use which were given to me by my sister because she didn't like them. Oh man, everyone is moving their stuff around.

Stuff, a plan -- Today, coincidentally, I read one of my old blog posts where I talked about a project I was doing during of the 40 days of Lent that year. I got rid of a bag of stuff every day. 40 bags in 40 days. Lent is the season before Easter. This coming year Lent starts on March 5th. I commit right now to getting rid of 40 bags (grocery bag size, not garbage bags) of stuff before Easter. Hold me to it.
Don and his brother talking football.

Football and soup: We have technically entered the soup time of year. We try to eat a nice warm bowl of soup every evening for our dinner. If you have a favorite soup recipe, please share! / Football. Our team UO Ducks, is doing well. Saturday evening (today) they play for the league championship. If all goes well, they will be in the 12-team tournament. Fingers crossed. Don is absolutely in his element these days.

Books: If I remember correctly, I offloaded several bags of books to the library for their book sales during my last 40 in 40 challenge. Glancing over at my bookshelf which I can see from where I sit, it is clearly time to tidy it up and bag up books for a donation. 

Here is what I am reading right now:
  • Christmas Pudding by Nancy Mitford. Published in the 1930s, the book is certainly a look at a bygone era. I meant to read this during November for my novella challenge. Print. 14%.
  • Knife: Meditations After an Attempted Murder by Salman Rushdie. Another short book I'd hope to read in November. As you know, Rushdie was nearly killed by a knife attack. He lost an eye. This is a look at his life and reflections since that event. Print. 19%.
  • The Japanese Lover by Isabel Allende. A book club selection. Audio. 40%.
Books I've recently finished:
  • Piranesi by Susanna Clarke. A Women's Prize winner. What a special book. Audio.
  • Modern Poetry by Diane Seuss. A National Book Award finalist. Print.
  • How to Be More Tree by Liz Marvin. One of those cute little inspirational books which is illustrated. Love it. Print.
Blog posts you may have missed:
The Nikon Comedy Wildlife Award: If you need a smile today, visit this website to enjoy photos of all the comedy wildlife antics. Here is my favorite:

Christina Haines. "Saying my prayers."

Vote: Which books should I read for my One Big Book 2025 Challenge? Help me decide!


-Anne 

6-Degrees of Separation -- from SANDWICH to ...

It’s time for #6degrees of separation. We all start at the same place as other wonderful readers, add six books, and see where we end up.

This week I created a spreadsheet of Best Books of 2024 End-of-the-Year 
(BBEOTY) lists. I found seventeen lists, to be precise. All the books on this 6-degrees list are mentioned on some of these lists. 

Six Degrees of Separation
Today we state with 

Sandwich by Catherine Newman. Is on five of the best-books-end-of-the-year (BBEOTY) lists so far. My book club is considering this one for an upcoming meeting.

Playground by Richard Powers. Is another book the my club is considering. It is on six of the BBEOTY lists. This is a favorite author of mine.

The Mighty Red by Louise Erdrich. Another book with six BBEOTY mentions. This is also written by a favorite author. 

Rejection by Tony Tulathimutte. I hadn't heard of this books until I started looking at the BBEOTY. This book is on seven lists. It is a collection of interconnected stories.

You Like It Darker by Stephen King. Another story collection. This one by a very popular author but not on as many BBEOTY lists, only two.

Intermezzo by Sally Rooney. Another very popular author. But this book is on eight BBEOTY lists.

James by Percival Everett. The only book on this list I've read. It is one of the best books of the year. It's on thirteen BBEOTY lists. It is also our next book club selection.


-Anne

Thursday, December 5, 2024

Review: HOW TO BE BOTH (+Friday56 LinkUp)



Title:
How to Be Both by Ali Smith

Book Beginnings quote: EYES, page 1

Friday56 quote: EYES, p. 47


Summary: 
How to be both is a novel all about art’s versatility. Borrowing from painting’s fresco technique to make an original literary double-take, it’s a fast-moving genre-bending conversation between forms, times, truths and fictions. There’s a Renaissance artist of the 1460s. There’s the child of a child of the 1960s. Two tales of love and injustice twist into a singular yarn where time gets timeless, structural gets playful, knowing gets mysterious, fictional gets real—and all life’s givens get given a second chance.

A NOTE TO THE READER:
Who says stories reach everybody in the same order?
This novel can be read in two ways and this book provides you with both.
In half of all printed editions of the novel the narrative EYES comes before CAMERA. In the other half of printed editions the narrative CAMERA precedes EYES. The narratives are exactly the same in both versions, just in a different order.
Review: Oh boy. This book is unique. First, you can start it at the heading CAMERA or EYES. Together the two sides make up a complete story told from a different vantage point. The audiobook I listened to began at CAMERA which is a more modern story of a girl who is deep in grief after the death of her mother, thinking back when she and her mother interacted with art. One episode led them to Italy to visit a fresco done by a group of artists where one artist's work was clearly better than the others in the room. After finishing the CAMERA side I listened to the EYE side, which was the story of that good artist, what life was like during the Renaissance for artists. The first quote is when this artist is pulled into the 21st century and can see the girl as she goes about her daily life beginning with her sitting in front of a painting in an art museum.

The book is extremely clever and odd, frustrating and satisfying, and very unique. I had no idea what I was getting myself into when I began the book and from the audio I heard the directions about starting at CAMERA or EYES. Oh boy, hang on, I thought. Why did I pick How to Be Both? Earlier in the year I set myself a challenge to read the winner or finalist for the last decade of Women's Prize Book Award winners. How to Be Both won the prize in 2015. It also won a ton of other awards that year, obviously because the book is so unique. It also ended up on the NYT list of 100 best books of the 21st century. I am attempting to some read books from that list, too, so I double-dipped with my selection of How to Be Both. That said, just because a book wins an award or ends up on a prestigious list doesn't make it popular or easy-to-read. And How to Be Both is not easy to read, as evidenced by the (pages-long) poem which starts the EYES half of the book. I think listening to the audiobook helped prevent some confusion but might have caused other issues. For one, I wasn't aware of the poem format, which may have been a blessing. And look at the punctuation in the second quote with all those colons. There are no colons in audiobooks!

An interesting side note: the photo on the cover of the two women makes it into the storyline several times. I found myself looking at that photo over and over again. Once again, the versatility of art!

My rating: 3.5. I liked the book but didn't fully understand it.






Sign up for The Friday56 on the Inlinkz below. 

RULES:

*Grab a book, any book
*Turn to page 56 or 56% in your e-reader (If you want to improvise, go ahead!)
*Find a snippet, but no spoilers!
*Post it to your blog and add your url to the Linky below. If you do not add the specific url for your post, we may miss it! 
*Visit other blogs and leave comments about their snippets. Expand the community. Please leave a comment for me, too!  


Also visit Book Beginnings on Friday hosted by Rose City Reader and First Line Friday hosted by Reading is My Super Power to share the beginning quote from your book.

You are invited to the Inlinkz link party!

Click here to enter

-Anne

Monday, December 2, 2024

TTT: Christmas/Holiday Stories I'd Like to Read or Reread


Top Ten Tuesday: Christmas/Holiday Stories I'd Like to Read (for the first time) or Reread (again and again)



I grew up in a household where How the Grinch Stole Christmas (Seuss) and The Best Christmas Pageant Ever (Robinson) were read aloud every year, year after year. I've heard them both so many times I'm sure I could recite them word-for-word from memory. Several years ago I added a third must-read holiday book to the mix: The Shepherd, the Angel, and Walter the Miracle Christmas Dog (Barry). Will I read them, all three, again this year? Yes! Will I ever get sick of them? Never! That said, variety is the spice of life and I am ready to add more holiday-themed books to my yearly repertoire. Here are a few I want to read or reread this year:

The Mitford Snowman: A Christmas Story by Jan Kanon. Years ago I read several books in the Mitford series and I'm sure there will be recognizable characters in this short, 23 page booklet. I just got a copy from the library today so I can safely say this one will get read this year..
 
Christmas Pudding by Nancy Mitford. Set in England between the 1st and 2nd wars, published in 1932. This author was recommended to me by another person participating in the Novellas in November Challenge. I have also received a copy of this book from the library so it is likely I will read it for the first time in 2024.


The Autobiography of Santa Claus As told to Jeff Guinn. This book is right up my alley. A little mythology mixed with a bit of real history. I am checking my library to see if they have an available copy to borrow.


A Christmas Carol by Charles Dickens. Believe it or not I read this Christmas classic for the first time ever this year. I was obviously very familiar with the story but still found out a few new parts of the story, which delighted me.



The Secret History of Christmas by Bill Bryson. Only available in audio format. Read by the author. This was the first book I finished in 2024 and I'm ready to listen to it again this Christmas season. I actually learned a lot first time through it. 


A Christmas Story by Jean Shepherd. Pulling stories from several volumes of stories by the author and gathering them together to make up this book and the movie we all know and love. I've read this several times. Maybe 2024 would be a good year for a reread of this hilarious gem.

A Redbird Christmas by Fannie Flagg. Every book I've read by this author, I've loved. I am pretty sure I had this book in my high school library so it is shocking I never read it during my days as a librarian. Time to change that. 

A Christmas Memory, One Christmas, & The Thanksgiving Visitor by Truman Capote. Just last week I read this story collection about holiday memories by Capote. What remarkable stories! What a remarkable author. Since I bought a used copy of this book I bet this book, of all the books I've listed, will become my must-read holiday book.


The Wood at Midwinter by Susanna Clarke. A new book by a new-to-me author. I just finished Piranesi today and then saw this book. Adding it to my TBR and getting in line for the library copy!


Dinosaur vs. Santa by Bob Shea. I discovered this book last Christmas and read it with my grandsons. They loved it and read through the whole series of Dinosaur vs. books with their parents. When I saw it at the library today I snapped it up immediately and had a fun reread with my youngest grandson. "Dinosaur wins!"


What holiday book(s) do you read/reread often? Please leave a comment for me. Help me expand my holiday reading options. Thanks.

-Anne

Sunday, December 1, 2024

Novellas in November Wrap-Up


Novellas in November is over for 2024 and I had a very successful month of reading. It even surprised me to note how many books I was able to read and review. 

In total I completed 19 novellas, or short books. I DNF'd one book. I reviewed all but one of the books. To my delight I was able to finish several classic novellas which have long resided on my TBR pile: A Christmas Carol, Giovanni's Room, The Death of Ivan Ilyich, The Turn of the Screw, A Room of One's Own. I read several books I never would have picked up if not for this challenge (All Systems Red, A Strange Library) and found new favorites (Foster, Truman Capote's Stories, Orbital). I even read the best novel noone has ever heard of: Pedro Páramo. It was a good month!

Here are my reviews, many posted in batches of three:


A Christmas Carol by Dickens
Dept. of Speculation by Offill
A Strange Library by Murakami


Giovanni's Room by Baldwin
The Death of Ivan Ilyich by Tolstoy
The Postman Always Rings Twice by Cain


Foster by Keegan
Buffalo Dream by Duncan
All Systems Red by Wells


10 Single review and group read:
Orbital by Harvey


11 Single Classic review:


Whereabouts by Lahiri
Rita Hayworth and the Shawshank Redemption by King
House Made of Dawn by Momaday


15 Single Classic review:
Pedro Páramo by Rulfo


Truman Capote Stories (A Christmas Memory; One Christmas; and The Thanksgiving Visitor)
A Room of One's Own by Woolf
Another Brooklyn by Woodson


-Anne

Three Novella Reviews: TRUMAN CAPOTE STORIES; A ROOM OF ONE'S OWN; ANOTHER BROOKLYN


Today is November 30th. It is my last chance to highlight three more novellas completed this month. And what a way to go out.

Truman Capote: A Christmas Memory. One Christmas & The Thanksgiving Visitor. Modern Library, 1996. 107 pages.

Taking its place next to Breakfast at Tiffany's and In Cold Blood on the bookshelf is this new and original edition of Capote's most famous short stories: "A Christmas Memory, " "One Christmas, " and "The Thanksgiving Visitor." All three stories are distinguished by Capote's delicate interplay of childhood sensibility and recollective vision, evoking a strong sense of place. (Publisher)

I dropped by a used bookstore the other day, looking for a gift for my mother, a 95-year-old voracious reader. I found a few good books I know she will like but while I was perusing the shelves for one more, to round out the lot, this used Truman Capote short story collection caught my eye. I've read, in fact, I own a copy of "A Christmas Story," but was not familiar with the other two stories. Of particular interest to me was "The Thanksgiving Visitor" since we just celebrated that holiday. Since my husband was driving I started it before we left the store's parking lot. I completed the book this morning, devouring all three stories before handing it over to Mom.

Truman Capote had an especially hard childhood. One bereft of love from either parent. As a very young child he was shunted off to live with his mother's relatives in Alabama and there he found love and solace from a distant cousin, Miss. Sook, a 60-year-old who was very much like a child. Capote considered her his best friend. All three of the stories involve his adventures with Miss Sook. In "A Christmas Memory", Buddy, as he was called, and his friend make fruitcake and prepare for Christmas. Neither task was easy because it was The Depression and money was scarce. But the love and the fun were abundant. In "One Christmas," Buddy has to travel to New Orleans by himself to spend the holidays with his father, who he barely knows. His friend enticed him to go with the promise of possible snow. Buddy had his belief in Santa Claus shaken by a father who did not believe in magic. In the last story, "The Thanksgiving Visitor," Miss Sook invites Odd Henderson to join their family for Thanksgiving dinner. Odd is Buddy's tormentor at school and he wants nothing to do with the bully. Thanks to his best friend, a truce of sorts is reached and lesson is learned.

I loved all three stories and I hope to add this book to my Christmas-book reading rotation next year, after I retrieve this copy of the book from my mother.

Though not officially a novella, I am counting it as part of my Novellas in November challenge. At 107 pages it looks and feels like a novella.

Rating: 5 stars


Another Brooklyn by Jacqueline Woodson. Harper Collins, 2016. 175 pages.

Running into a long-ago friend sets memories from the 1970s in motion for August, transporting her to a time and a place where friendship was everything—until it wasn’t. For August and her girls, sharing confidences as they ambled through neighborhood streets, Brooklyn was a place where they believed that they were beautiful, talented, brilliant—a part of a future that belonged to them.

But beneath the hopeful veneer, there was another Brooklyn, a dangerous place where grown men reached for innocent girls in dark hallways, where ghosts haunted the night, where mothers disappeared. A world where madness was just a sunset away and fathers found hope in religion. (Publisher)

I finished up my Novellas in November challenge with an author I am very familiar with, Jacqueline Woodson. This book, Another Brooklyn, is her first foray into adult fiction, but it is every way just as poetic as her poetry-in-prose novels and memoirs meant for teens and preteens. Those books, however, were more straightforward. I found this book confusing as the narrator wanders around in her memory circling around the question of what happened to her mother. None of the characters were fully fleshed out, either, so when bad/sad/frustrating things happened to them I felt little compassion or empathy as a reader. Set during the early 1970s, there were a few cultural references to the events of the times, but most didn't really impact the story so their mention was just window dressing. Honestly, I like Woodson's Brown Girl Dreaming much better than this book if you are thinking of giving this author a try.

My rating: 3.5 stars.




A Room of One's Own by Virginia Woolf. Original publisher: Hogarth Press, 1929. 112 pages. Audiobook published by Fort Raphael Publishing Co., 2025. [Not a typo. This is the date stated on the audiobook.]

In A Room of One's Own, Virginia Woolf imagines that Shakespeare had a sister. A sister equal to Shakespeare in talent, and equal in genius, but whose legacy is radically different. This imaginary women never writes a word and dies by her own hand, her genius unexpressed. If only she had found the means to create, argues Woolf, she would have reached the same heights as her immortal sibling. In this classic essay, Virginia Woolf takes on the establishment, using her gift of language to dissect the world around her and give voice to those without. Her message is a simple one: women must have some money and a room of their own in order to have the freedom to create. (Publisher)

In 1928 Woolf was asked to give a series of lectures at Newnham and Girton colleges on the topic of 'Women and Fiction.' This small volume is a collection of essays based on those lectures. Though the book has a fictional narrator who tells the story of not only the research Woolf did in preparation but also her opinions about other female writers, of whom only Jane Austen and Emily Bronte gained her praise. The book is considered nonfiction, shelved in the social science section of a library, specifically under feminist literature. Technically, it is not a novella either, but we were assured tby hosts of Novellas in November that nonfiction titles were allowed. Woolf is a spectacular writer.

I don't know how I managed to live over 60 years without reading this classic very feminist book about what women need to be self-sufficient and equal to men in power and talent. Even a hundred years after these essays were written we are still struggling to reach a true level of equality, which completely gauls me. In fact, I couldn't help thinking of the results of the 2024 US election being, at least in part, due to misogyny. Grr. 

I started out reading the print edition but found it very difficult to read due to the pages-long paragraphs. I switched to the audio version, narrated by Sara Nichols. Since I purchased it with an Audible credit I can urge my daughters to listen to it and there will be no impediment to their access. I want my daughters to grow up believing they can do anything they want, not held back by their gender. I also want to reread it in a year or two as I'm sure I will get plenty of new insights from it on each reading.

My rating: 5 stars.


-Anne

Friday, November 29, 2024

Classic review: PEDRO PÁRAMO


Pedro Páramo: 

"The Perfect Novel You’ve Never Heard Of"(Slate)

About two years ago I read a list of 75 books one should read before they die. Pedro Páramo by Juan Rulfo was on that list. I had not heard of the book but figured it would be good for me to read more Latin American literature and added Pedro to my TBR list. Since then I've noticed the books on several other must-read lists and noted an upcoming Netflix film adaptation. It was time to get more serious about locating a copy of this classic book.

First I searched the library and found that all of their print versions had a long waiting list. The library had an audiobook available, which I prefer anyway, but on closer inspection I determined the recording was in Spanish. Since that wouldn't work for me I went ahead and used an Audible credit to purchase the English translation audiobook. My next challenge was to find a time to listen to the book with my husband who is better at interpreting magical realism or books with deeper meanings than me. Since Pedro Páramo is short, less than 130 pages and only 4-1/2 hours listening time, we were able to complete the book on a recent car trip. And, boy, was I glad Don listened to it with me. 

Wikipedia describes Pedro Páramo this way, "This novel showcases the roots of Mexican culture and its beliefs on afterlife through deeply complex characters, spirituality, and a constant transition between realms/dimensions that encompass a nonlinear chronology." Well, that doesn't sound confusing at all (snark)! To add to the mixed-up timelines, the shifting narrators and verb tenses switch back and forth so often that time itself has no meaning. The first/main narrator, Juan Preciado, travels to his mother's hometown, Comala, to confront the father he has never met, Pedro Páramo. When he reaches Comala Juan meets ghost after ghost, though distinguishing the living from the dead is an ongoing and futile effort. The town itself seems to be disintegrating. Through these ghosts Juan learns about the history of this town and of his father. The memories they share do not match up exactly with the memories his mother shared with him before her death. In the end, before he is literally scared to death, he learns the town has become a ghost town because of his father. Everyone died because of Pedro Páramo's cruelty. 

At some point during the trip -- midbook, actually -- I looked up information about Pedro Páramo on Shmoop, my favorite go-to spot for literary criticism. The book plays with the question "what is reality anyway?" The reader is never really sure what just happened. "The chorus of ghosties helps keep this sense of dread rolling around in your head not only when you are reading but long afterwards. Isn't that the definition of being haunted?"

A book becomes a classic when it is never done saying what it has to say, making a rereading likely. Pedro Páramo has a lot to say about spirituality and religion, time and memory, madness and suffering, gender differences, and culture and history. The author, Juan Rulfo, was speaking to issues that Mexicans living in the 1950s would understand about the death of rural communities as people were leaving for urban centers and various abuses of the Catholic church. These themes and many others are ones we can still relate to today. Rulfo also played with the names of the characters that perhaps only Spanish speaking readers would immediately understand. Many character names were clearly carefully chosen to reflect personalities, fates, or themes. For example Abundio Martinez, with a name that implies abundance, starves to death.

The version of Pedro Páramo we listened to was translated by Douglas Weatherford, who included an endnote describing his efforts to translate the text the way it was written, which may be a bit more confusing to English readers than other previous translations. Gabriel Garcia Marqués wrote the forward and extolled Rulfo's book and writing in general. Marquez credits Rulfo with really opening up his own career -- and for many other famous Latin American authors -- which we know included the very highly regarded One Hundred Years of Solitude. He read Pedro Páramo over and over. Marquez thinks he could actually recite the book line for line from cover to cover. High praise for a book I had never even heard of.

My rating: 4 stars.

At 122 pages, Pedro Paramo qualifies for Novelas in November.



-Anne

Thursday, November 28, 2024

Review: THE WOMEN IN THE CASTLE (+Friday56 LinkUp)


Title:
The Women in the Castle by Jessica Shattuck

Book Beginnings quote:
The day of the countess's famous harvest party began with a driving rain that hammered down on all the ancient von Lingenfels castle's sore spots -- springing leaks, dampening floors, and turning its yellow facade a slick, beetle-like black. In the courtyard, the paper lanterns and carefully strung garlands of wheat drooped and collapsed.
Friday56 quote:
The rest of the evening passed pleasantly. There was no further talk of politics, and Connie seemed truly interested in learning all about her. Benita had never been asked so many questions.
Summary: 
Amid the ashes of Nazi Germany’s defeat, Marianne von Lingenfels returns to the once-grand castle of her husband’s ancestors, an imposing stone fortress now fallen into ruin following years of war. The widow of a Nazi resister murdered in the failed July 20, 1944, plot to assassinate Adolf Hitler, Marianne plans to uphold the promise she made to her husband’s brave conspirators: to find and protect their wives, her fellow resistance widows.
Review: The Women in the Castle was this month's book club selection. Every gal who braved the windy forecast for a 'bomb cyclone' said they really enjoyed the book. So did I. Oddly and to a person, we all noticed the similarities between the politics of Germany in the 1930s and 40s under the Nazis and what we are experiencing today in American politics. We had to stop ourselves from talking about one issue just to move on and discuss other questions from the publisher. Shattuck said the story was related to her family story but didn't elaborate on that note. Did she mean her grandparents were Nazi resisters like the characters in the book? Or did she just mean that her grandparents had to live through the lean years after WWII were Germans were forced to confront their complicity in the Holocaust even if they were ignorant, as most said? Shattuck also said that the book took her seven years to write and it was published in 2017. There is no way she knew what kind of politics Trump would bring forward, or embrace at the time of her writing. So we decided her book was unintentionally prescient. 

Most WWII books stop at wars end. This book is mainly set after the war's end when Marianne sets out to find and protect the other resister's widows. She finds two and brings them and their children to live with her in the old family castle that is a cold and leaky place. The stories of these three women, and to a smaller degree their children, populate the book. War has all kinds of victims. Some die in the fighting, others can't seem to make sense of their lives after it is over. This book addresses those grey zones of life in the shadows and aftermath of war.

Discussion questions for The Women in the Castle (from Lit Lovers):

1. What does the novel reveal about the method and degree of Hitler's appeal to the German populace? In what way does it address the most problematic question of the War: how the German people allowed themselves to be swept away by Hitler and Nazi propaganda. Just as important, how much—and at what point—did ordinary citizens truly know about the impoundment and murder of Europe's Jewish population.

2. Describe each of the three women—Marianne, Ania, and Benita. Talk about their different views of the Hitler regime as it unfolded and their various reasons for supporting it. What was each woman's role, or position, in German society, and how did each experience the war? What about the years after the war?

3. Which woman's story do you find most compelling, frightening, or horrifying? Are you more sympathetic toward one than the other two?

4. Most of the recent books about World War II focus on the horrors of the holocaust, and for good reason. Yet ordinary Germans also suffered, especially as the war neared the end. What was it like for the country as Nazism collapsed? Consider the population at large, but most particularly the women at Burg Lingenfels. How are the three of them luckier than most survivors?

5. What roles do hope…denial…and forgiveness play in this novel? Is Jessica Shattuck's book an attempt to somehow exonerate the citizens who supported Hitler's rise to power?

*6. What comparisons can you make between the politics of the 1930s/40s in Germany and those of today in the US?

*7. WWII has certainly been fodder for a lot of books and movies. What are you favorites about this topic? How does this book compare to those?


Sign up for The Friday56 on the Inlinkz below. 

RULES:

*Grab a book, any book
*Turn to page 56 or 56% in your e-reader (If you want to improvise, go ahead!)
*Find a snippet, but no spoilers!
*Post it to your blog and add your url to the Linky below. If you do not add the specific url for your post, we may miss it! 
*Visit other blogs and leave comments about their snippets. Expand the community. Please leave a comment for me, too!  


Also visit Book Beginnings on Friday hosted by Rose City Reader and First Line Friday hosted by Reading is My Super Power to share the beginning quote from your book.

You are invited to the Inlinkz link party!

Click here to enter


-Anne